USA
• Alderson-Broaddus College (Philippi, WV), NCAA Division II independent (2012)
• Berry College (Rome, GA), NCAA Division III / Southern Athletic Association (2013)
• Bluefield College (Bluefield, VA), NAIA / Mid-South Conference (club-level team in 2011, varsity team in 2012)
• Finlandia University (Hancock, MI), NCAA Division III / independent (?) (2013)
• Florida Tech (Melbourne, FL), NCAA Division II / Gulf South Conference (2013)
• Hendrix College (Conway, AR), NCAA Division III / Southern Athletic Association (2013)
• Houston Baptist University (Houston, TX), NCAA Division I - Football Championship Subdivision / Southland Conference (2013)
• College of Idaho (Caldwell, ID), NAIA (probably 2014)
• Kennesaw State (Kennesaw, GA), NCAA Division I - Football Championship Subdivision (?) (possibly 2014)
• George Fox University (Newberg, OR), NCAA Division III / Northwest Conference (2013)
• Lindenwood University-Belleville (Belleville, IL), affiliation uncertain (2012?)
• Mercer University (Macon, GA), NCAA Division I - Football Championship Subdivision (2013)
• Misericordia University (Dallas, PA), NCAA Division III / Middle Atlantic Conference (2012)
• University of New Orleans (New Orleans, LA), NCAA Division II (no later than 2015)
• Oklahoma Baptist University (Shawnee, OK), NAIA (2013)
• Point University (East Point, GA), club-level in 2011, NAIA in 2012 (school was previously Atlanta Christian College and will relocate to West Point, GA in 2012)
• Reinhardt University (Waleska, GA), NAIA (2013)
• Siena Heights University (Adrian, MI), NAIA / Mid-States Football Association (2012)
• Southwestern University (Georgetown, TX), NCAA Division III / Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference (2013)
• Stetson University (DeLand, FL), NCAA Division I - Football Championship Subdivision (2013)
• UNC Charlotte (Charlotte, NC), NCAA Division I - Football Championship Subdivision (2013)
• Wayland Baptist University (Plainview, TX), NAIA / Central States Football League (2012)
Junior Colleges
• Monroe College (New Rochelle, NY) (2012)
Canada
• Carleton (Ottawa, ON) (2013)

There certainly may be others as well which I have not heard about, so please let me know if you have any additions! (including colleges in Canada and junior or community colleges).

New Teams for 2012

ALDERSON-BROADDUS

This college's athletic teams are called the "Battlers" and the school colors are blue and gold. No information has been received regarding the team's future helmet design.

BLUEFIELD

According to information posted at the team's web site, this helmet design has already been chosen for future use by the Bluefield "Rams".

MISERICORDIA

Misericordia's team will be known as the "Cougars" and the school colors are blue and gold. No helmet design information has yet been received for this team.

MONROE COLLEGE

The Monroe team will be known as the "Mustangs" and the school colors are listed as blue and gold.

POINT UNIVERSITY

Point's athletic teams are now called the "Skyhawks" and the school colors are blue and gold. I have not yet received any definite information as to what the football team's helmets will look like, but photographs have appeared at the team's web site (as of April 2012) showing dark blue helmets with a lighter blue "wing" logo on the sides.

SIENA HEIGHTS

Siena Heights' football team will be called the "Saints" and the school colors are blue and gold. During the 2011 football season the JV team at Siena Heights used the helmet design shown above, and it has been reported to me that the varsity team which begins play in 2012 will also use this design.

WAYLAND BAPTIST

WBU's team will be known as the "Pioneers" and the school colors are blue and gold. A couple of different "prop" helmets have appeared in photographs at the future team's web site but I do not know if any of these have actually been chosen for use by the team.

New Team for 2013

MERCER

This design has been announced for future use by the Mercer "Bears".

Other colleges which may start football teams

Below are listed some other colleges which may be adding football as a varsity sport in the near future, or which at least appear to be considering doing so, and some others which have recently rejected the idea. For each of these, it is my impression that the addition of football is not yet a certainty. (There are probably many others besides those listed here; reports about additional schools, both in the United States and Canada, would be appreciated.)

• Alvernia University (Reading, PA) - This school announced in January 2011 that it was forming a committee to consider the addition of other intercollegiate sports teams, including football. At an unknown later time (during or before August 2011) the school announced that "football will not be feasible or advisable for the next three years." (source: http://www.wfmz.com/news/28673874/detail.html )
• Brewton-Parker College (Mount Vernon, GA) - This school announced in July 2009 that it would soon commence a "Football Feasibility Study". The college had a football team previously which played its last season in 1946. Brewton-Parker is a member of the NAIA for other sports. (source: http://www.christianindex.org/5618.article )
• Calvin College (Grand Rapids, MI) - a final decision about whether an intercollegiate football team will be started at this Michigan college is expected by the end of the 2011-2012 academic year ( source ). Calvin's other athletic teams participate as members of NCAA Division III.
• Cleveland State (Cleveland, OH) - In November 2008, CSU President Michael Schwartz appointed a committee "to study whether it makes sense for the school to field a football team"; the school was at the same time considering a name change to "University of Cleveland". However, in January 2009, it was announced that neither of these plans was likely to be implemented in the near future. (source: http://www.clevelandleader.com/node/8624)
• East Tennessee State (Johnson City, TN) - A return of intercollegiate football to this university in the near future now appears unlikely. In April 2007, ETSU students voted by a margin of 59% to 41% against a proposed increase in the student athletic fee which would have helped fund a return of football to the school. "Student approval was the first of several steps needed for the return of football" (source: ETSU press release at http://www.etsubucs.com/sports/football/release.asp?RELEASE_ID=9812). ETSU had a football team previously, which was discontinued following the 2003 season.
• Erskine College (Due West, SC) - "At the request of the student services/athletic committee, the [college's Board of Trustees] approved a formal, detailed feasibility study for the possibility of football. Smith said the study should include the impact of football on academics, finances and culture at the college." (Source: article entitled "Erskine Board of Trustees approves new mission statement for college", dated October 19, 2007, posted at the college's web site. )
• Florida Gulf Coast University (Fort Myers, FL) - This college has recently considered the formation of an intercollegiate football team but (as of March 2011) will apparently not be doing so for at least several years, with the expense of adding such a team being the main reason. " 'Right now, it probably won’t work,' [Florida Gulf Coast University Board of Trustees Chairman Scott] Lutgert said. 'It’s probably 5-10 years down the road – 5-10 years down the road to make the decision to start doing it … that puts it at 10-15 years down the road.'” (source: http://www.championshipsubdivisionnews.com/log/index.php/2011/01/28/fgcu-athletics-board-of-trustees-chair-a?blog=2 )
• Florida Memorial (Miami Gardens, FL) - This Historically Black college apparently has intentions of starting an intercollegiate football team (see "Task 1.2.2"): http://74.125.93.132/search?q=cache:nF2cWr2Ik0EJ:www.fmuniv.edu/uploads/01/21/0121433c92832c0be76f862b9095a4d2/ADMObjTasks-12-13Fnl.doc
• Grand Canyon University (Phoenix, AZ) - This school announced in January, 2008 that it would be adding an intercollegiate football team in 2009, but has apparently cancelled those plans. The following statement appeared in an article at the university's web site, dated August 21, 2009: "At one point, football was considered at Grand Canyon, but much like the aforementioned schools [Gonzaga, Marquette, Xavier], it was determined that the sport would be a drain on the university's resources and jeopardize the other programs". (source: http://www.gcu.edu/index.php?mact=News,cntnt01,detail,0&cntnt01articleid=95&cntnt01returnid=69 )
• High Point University (High Point, NC) - University president Nido Qubein has stated that football is "inevitable" at HPU, though it may be several years before a team comes to fruition. Land on which to build a stadium is one of the needs mentioned in this article.
• Indiana Wesleyan University (Marion, IN) - In October 2010 this school announced that it had initiated "studies" for the possible addition of an intercollegiate football team (source: http://www.iwuwildcats.com/article/1832.php ). However, as of April 2011, it appears that football will not be added in the near future: "The Blue Ribbon Commission recommended that football would be a positive addition to the Indiana Wesleyan community but will not move forward on adding the sport at this time. Football was not deemed a top priority for the institution right now and funding for the sport is not currently available. 'The Blue Ribbon Committee results show that football will be a positive addition to Indiana Wesleyan University given the availability of the necessary resources to do it at a competitive level,' said Indiana Wesleyan athletic director Mark DeMichael. 'It is understood currently that other university initiatives should take precedent over the addition of football. So football will be placed on the backburner. The financial feasibility of adding football will be revisited each year.'" (source: http://www.iwuwildcats.com/article/2151.php).
• Lee University (Cleveland, TN) - This southeastern Tennessee school is apparently considering the addition of a football team as of April 2012, and a consultant has been hired to advise the university on related considerations (source: http://leeclarion.com/featured/2012/04/22/lee-considering-football-and-move-to-ncaa/ ).
• Limestone College (Gaffney, SC) - Administrators of this school are considering the addition of football as an intercollegiate sport as of May 2012; a feasibility study has already been completed. A Limestone football team would compete at the NCAA Division II level. (source: http://www.goupstate.com/article/20120502/ARTICLES/120509909/1088/sports?Title=Limestone-College-mulling-a-football-program ).
• LeMoyne-Owen College (Memphis, TN) - this Historically Black college is apparently again considering the addition of football as an intercollegiate sport: "A feasibility committee will recommend that LeMoyne-Owen College field a football team starting in 2012. The recommendation, based on expectations that football will drive up enrollment, will be made to president Johnnie B. Watson -- who seems inclined to approve it and send it to the Board of Trustees for the final OK." (source: http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/2010/oct/21/magicians-closer-on-football/ ). As of April 2012 there is no clear indication yet at the school's web site as to whether a football team will play in 2012.
• Lynchburg College (Lynchburg, VA) - This Virginia college has apparently decided (as of February 2008) to not add football as an intercollegiate sport, upon determining that the sport would be too expensive: "A recent task force determined that while students and alumni want football, it would come with an approximately $10 million price tag. 'We would not want to do a program unless it were done with quality, and at this point, we don’t think that’s what we’d like to do,' said Dr. Kenneth R. Garren, the school’s president. 'If someone came up and said, "Mr. President, we have $10 million and we would like you to start a football program," I’m certain we’d take another look at the situation. But if someone were to come up and say, "Mr. President, we have $10 million, how do you want to spend it?" It would not be on the football program.'" (source: http://www.schoolandcollegeva.com/scv/lifestyles/college/article/lynchburg-college-wont-start-football-team/110582/ )
• Nova Southeastern University (Miami, FL) - An article (http://ramblinwreck.cstv.com/sports/m-footbl/orange-bowl-central.html) about Georgia Tech's participation in the 2010 Orange Bowl mentioned that "With 15 athletic programs, NSU currently doesn't have a football team ... They will field one beginning in 2011". However, this statement appears to have been erroneous; according to a more recent article (http://uwire.com/2010/06/29/no-football-for-nova-southeastern-u/), NSU's Director of Athletics, Michael Mominey, has stated that “NSU will not be and has not considered the addition of football to its athletic program".
• Oglethorpe University (Atlanta, GA) - Football is being considered along with several other sports by this Atlanta college, which needs to add two additional sports as part of its membership in the new Southern Athletic Association. The school's athletic director would prefer to add sports other than football, and a decision may be made by May 2012 (source: http://brookhaven.patch.com/articles/oglethorpe-mulls-adding-football-to-sports-program ).
• Oklahoma Wesleyan (Bartlesville, OK) - A brief mention in this article that this school has "talked about adding football" recently (July 2010).
• Paine College (Augusta, GA) - As of January 2012 this historically Black college "has started a feasibility study" to consider the addition of football as an intercollegiate sport (source: http://www.wrdw.com/sports/headlines/Paine_College_looks_to_add_football_137621853.html?ref=853 ). Paine participates in the NCAA Division II Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference for other sports.
• Southeastern University (Lakeland, FL) - A short article dated March 8, 2012 mentions that this school - which is a member of the NAIA for other sports - will be "forming a committee to do research on if it would be feasible to add [football]" as an intercollegiate sport (source: http://www.theledger.com/article/20120308/NEWS/120309380?Title=Southeastern-Explores-Adding-NAIA-Football ).
• Texas A&M - Corpus Christi - "The decision on whether football has a future at Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi now rests with University leaders who have additional study ahead of them. The anticipated report on the feasibility of adding football to Texas A&M-Corpus Christi’s intercollegiate athletics program was delivered recently to campus officials by Indianapolis-based NACDA Consulting. The report outlines the physical and financial requirements and expectations for having an intercollegiate football program.v “This report does not make a final recommendation on adding football to our sports program, but provides us the data and research to help evaluate the requirements if football is to be feasible for A&M-Corpus Christi in time,” University President Flavius Killebrew said. “We have many factors to consider over the coming months regarding whether football is the best fit in coming years for the university, the students and the community" (source: http://www.nacdaconsulting.com/news/details.asp?ArticleSource=70 ; article dated January 22, 2007).
• Trevecca Nazarene University (Nashville, TN) - An article (dated 2011 July 11) about this school's move from NAIA participation to the NCAA mentioned that the creation of a football team was also being considered: "...Trevecca, which will introduce a new athletics director on Tuesday, is open to the possibility that it could add football in the coming years. Neither [local rival colleges] Lipscomb nor Belmont, which compete in NCAA Division I, have football. 'That will be on our study chart very rapidly,' Trevecca President Dan Boone said. Football actually could become a central issue as to whether or not the university gains full-time D-II membership following the necessary transition period, typically a three-year process." (source: http://nashvillecitypaper.com/content/sports/trevecca-nazarene-charts-own-course-move-ncaa )
• Utah Valley University (Orem, UT) - The student body at this college appears to have a strong interest in adding an intercollegiate football team, but the administration has concerns pertaining to the cost and to the likely degree of community support for such a team. "'The big problem is just the limited resources we have and the fact that we're needing to finance our current athletic programs. We've got to take care of those first,' (UVU President William A.) Sederburg said. 'Then we need to figure out how to get the attendance up and make sure that we can do it right.' UVU is still trying to establish its athletic teams at the NCAA Division I level, the president said, and he doesn't want to disrupt that by trying to work football into the mix. 'My sense is we're not ready to go there,' Sederburg said. 'The students are pushing it, and we have an obligation to pay attention to what the students are saying. I think in time UVU will have a football team, but probably not in the near future.'" If established, the UVU team would compete at the NCAA Division I-AA level. (Source: http://deseretnews.com/dn/view/0,1249,635168661,00.html)
• Virginia Commonwealth University (Richmond, VA) - As of February 2012 the university is reported to be considering the addition of football as an intercollegiate sport (source: http://www.nbc12.com/story/14219581/vcu-wants-city-stadium-talks-about-possibility-of-football ).
• University of West Florida (Pensacola, FL) - A "Football Feasibility Committee" is expected to meet for a final recommendation (about whether UWF should add football as an intercollegiate sport) on May 10, 2011 (source: http://www.goargos.com/page.asp?articleID=4450 )
• Winthrop (Rock Hill, SC) - This college may be considering the addition of a varsity football team: "Recent estimates indicate starting an intercollegiate football team at Winthrop would be a multi-million dollar proposition –over $18 million, much of it in facilities costs, just to get to the first kick-off – with over $2.4 million in annual operating and scholarship costs after that. University President Anthony DiGiorgio said he created a task force last year to come up with those estimates, among other things, so he would have a detailed answer to a question he’s been hearing every autumn for some years: “What would it take for us to have football at Winthrop?” That task force -- part of a larger group doing a 10-year projection of prospects for the overall athletics program -- sees identifying the level of potential donor support as the first question to be answered in determining how feasible it might be for Winthrop to field an Eagles football team, DiGiorgio said Tuesday. To generate that discussion, DiGiorgio authorized Athletics Director Tom Hickman, who chairs the task force, to release to the public details of the cost estimates developed by the task force now, ahead of completion of the final report. That will enable the task force to take stock of the public reaction to the “real dollars and cents” part of the question, see what donor support might step forward, and make that assessment part of the task force report before it is finalized. “It’s the fundamental feasibility question that must be addressed before exploring such a step any further,” DiGiorgio said. “Where would the money come from? Over what period of time? Football these days is an extraordinarily expensive sport for an institution to offer as part of its athletics program. The start-up costs are daunting and the operating costs are formidable. For our type institution, gate receipts would constitute only a part of any realistic financial plan. There are capital costs, personnel costs, and scholarship costs to be considered – and all those come before the first kick-off. Public tax dollars aren’t available for this, and Winthrop has other priorities for whatever tax dollars are available anyway. That leaves donor and fan support as the principal bases of support to be assessed. We are in a fortunate situation at Winthrop now, in that our existing athletics program is on firm enough footing that we can look at this question.” (source: undated "Media Relations News Release" from the university, available at www.winthropeagles.com/upload/upload2291_Football_Story_Revised.pdf)
• Wisconsin-Milwaukee: This school, which had a football team in 1974 and earlier years, may be considering reinstating the sport: "UWM is paying a Washington, D.C., consulting firm $87,450 to put together a strategic sports plan for the school. Part of that study will look into the possibility of fielding a football team" (source: http://www.jsonline.com/blogs/sports/133066738.html , article dated November 2, 2011.)